By SARAH ZIMMERMAN Associated Press
SALEM, Ore. (AP) — Oregon's foster care system has failed to shield children from abuse and they are sometimes forced to stay in refurbished jail cells and homeless shelters, according to a lawsuit filed Tuesday.
It’s a BIG day for ABC! On behalf of #ORfosterchildren, A Better Childhood and our partners: @DisabilityRtsOR @DWTLaw have filed a lawsuit against @OregonGovBrown and Oregon DHS. We have the opportunity to transform Oregon’s child welfare system, let's go! #ORfostercare pic.twitter.com/ALmzru0OWs— A Better Childhood (@ABChildhood) April 16, 2019
Gratitude to @OregonDHS and @OregonDHSCW . Today the child highlighted in last week’s hearing is home in OR and the agency has taken significant additional steps to place trusted eyes on 83 other children. Thank you for real & swift action! #orpol— Sara Gelser (@SenSaraGelser) April 16, 2019
The 77-page complaint filed in U.S. District Court details stories of foster children being neglected or harmed while under Department of Human Services care, including a 16-year-old girl sent to a juvenile jail after she had previously tried to kill herself.
The agency has weathered years criticism over the way it treats children and has paid out tens of millions of dollars to settle previous complaints.
"The big problem is that Oregon has failed to develop specialized placements or even enough placements for kids in care," said Marcia Lowry, executive director of A Better Childhood, one of the nonprofits behind the lawsuit. "Oregon goes well beyond what even the national problems are."
In a statement, DHS Director Fariborz Pakseresht said the agency is committed to finding children appropriate placement, especially those with intellectual and developmental disabilities. He said it is taking steps to address the problems identified in the lawsuit, and is finalizing a long-term, statewide plan to recruit more foster families.
DHS also plans to reassess its use of out-of-state facilities, he said.
At a legislative hearing last week, Pakseresht recognized flaws within the system, but maintained that the agency still provides quality services for the 7,500 youth in its care.
"We do make mistakes," Pakseresht told lawmakers. "A few mistakes - 10 mistakes, 20 mistakes, 30 mistakes - are never acceptable, but they don't constitute a system that is broken."
Since 2006, the agency has paid $39 million in legal settlements over allegations of abuse and neglect. But Christine Shank, one of the managing lawyers in the case, said the fundamental problems within DHS haven't changed.
"We're hoping this case can really be a catalyst for systemic change," said Shank, a lawyer with Disability Rights Oregon.
In the case of the 16-year-old girl, lawyers say she landed in state care after her father refused to get her mental health services. Her lawyers say she remained without therapy as she was shuffled between facilities, including homeless shelters, out of a lack of placement options.
At the Klamath Falls, Oregon, facility, which houses both juvenile inmates and at-risk foster youth, lawyers say the girl lived in a cinder-block cell where she couldn't keep any personal items except a book. She underwent daily extensive treatment for substance and sexual abuse, despite having never suffered from either. She had individualized therapy once a week, which her lawyers called inadequate.
The lawsuit argues DHS hasn't done enough to shield children from abuse and neglect, a violation of their federal due process rights. The lawsuit also says the department has failed to provide foster children with a permanent, stable living situation.
A 2016 federal audit found only 20% of foster children had "permanency and stability in their living conditions," while the majority were placed with foster parents who "may not have had the necessary skills" to care for them. The department made "concerted efforts" to provide children with permanent homes in 41% of cases.
Elizabeth Graves, who is not associated with the lawsuit, said she entered DHS care when she was 13, and was moved between 15 foster and group homes within five years. Now 27, she said she still suffers from nightmares over the emotional abuse she endured.
She became pregnant at 15, and said her circumstances began to improve when was sent to a Portland facility specifically serving girls who have young children or are pregnant. She received individualized attention plus parenting lessons.
But, less than an hour after Graves gave birth, she said DHS intervened and put her son up for adoption. According to Graves, her caseworker had determined she was too young to care for the child.
"I did everything to prepare for him," she told The Associated Press. "I spent all that time at the group home learning how to take care of him and even set up a room for him. I cried and begged but they just took him from me."
She now works as a credit card banker in Portland.
"I wouldn't have experienced the trauma I have today if I wasn't in foster care," she said. "I really hope this lawsuit finally does something. Kids are suffering and nobody is doing anything."
The lawsuit makes the following claims about problems in Oregon's foster care system:
- Overworked caseworkers struggle to make difficult decisions about the right services to provide—they have too many children to serve, too few resources, and too little training.
- Oregon fails to provide children in its care with necessary services and stable, nurturing, family-like placements—a lack of foster homes means children get placed in whatever home or placement is available rather than in a placement that is suitable.
- Foster children are shipped out of state at increasing rates, at great harm to the child’s wellbeing and at great expense to the state.
- Frequents moves among homes and institutions increase trauma for children already removed from troubled family homes and often separated from siblings, school, and community.
- DHS is unable to meet the needs of the more than 50% of foster children who experience physical, cognitive, or mental health disabilities.
- The system is not set up to get children the services and treatment many sorely need—foster children’s medical and mental health needs remain unmet due to irregular, infrequent assessments and the lack of sufficient and available resources to meet their needs.
- Older youth who lack appropriate transition supports are largely abandoned by the state when they “age out” of the system and often wind up in homeless shelters or on the streets.
- LGBTQ children, who are over-represented in the system, experience a higher number of placements due to a lack of LGBTQ-affirming foster homes as well as trauma caused by bullying and lack of supports.
- Oregon foster care system targeted in class action lawsuit
- Report: Oregon foster care system needs 'extensive work'
- State attorneys seek dismissal of Oregon foster care lawsuit
- Oregon's Attorney General Responds to Texas Lawsuit Targeting Affordable Care Act
- Audit: Oregon Foster Care Needs More Money, Culture Fix
- State audit reveals Oregon welfare programs and foster care mismanagement
- Tensions flare at strained hearing over Oregon foster care
- Caseworkers say staff shortages plague Oregon foster care
- SOU students, restaurants host foster care fundraisers
- Lawsuit Targets Utilities Over Wildfire, Mudslides