STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

Supreme Court agrees to take up major Second Amendment case

The Supreme Court announced it will consider the scope of the Second Amendment next term in a case concerning a New York law that restricts an individual from carrying a concealed handgun in public. CNN's Jessica Schneider has more.

Posted: Apr 26, 2021 9:44 AM


The Supreme Court announced Monday it will consider the scope of the Second Amendment next term in a case concerning a New York law that restricts an individual from carrying a concealed handgun in public.

It has been more than a decade since the justices have ruled on a significant case concerning the right to bear arms, and the court's decision to take the case comes in the wake of several mass shootings in the US and the Biden administration's push for enhanced gun regulations.

The court's move also highlights the impact of Justice Amy Coney Barrett's presence on the newly solidified conservative court. Justice Clarence Thomas and others had been urging the justices to take up the issue, and just last term, the court declined several cases.

In 2008, the court held for the first time that the Second Amendment protects an individual's right to keep and bear arms at home for self-defense. Except for a follow up decision two years later, the justices have largely stayed away from the issue, infuriating gun rights advocates and even some of the justices themselves.

"If a lower court treated another right so cavalierly, I have little doubt that this Court would intervene," Thomas wrote in a 2018 case. "But as evidenced by our continued inaction in this area, the 2nd Amendment is a disfavored right in this Court."

After the court effectively dismissed one case last term, Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote that he hoped that the justices would vote to take up a new case "soon." Still, in June, perhaps with the knowledge that there weren't five votes ready to decide, the court again declined to take up several new cases.

But the justices' decision on Monday could give the court an opportunity to revisit the 2008 majority opinion in District of Columbia v. Heller, which was penned by the late Justice Antonin Scalia, a conservative whose opinion has faced renewed scrutiny in recent weeks as the country grapples with a spate of deadly mass shootings.

In the 2008 ruling, Scalia, joined by four fellow conservatives, delved into the "originalist" understanding of the Framers in the 18th Century and concluded that the Second Amendment extended to private citizens -- a departure from how federal judges generally regarded the amendment as covering state militia, such as National Guards.

But Scalia's construction of history also led him to note some exceptions, for example, regarding concealed weapons. "(T)he majority of the 19th-century courts to consider the question held that prohibitions on carrying concealed weapons were lawful under the Second Amendment or state analogues," he wrote.

As the court reviews the case next term, there could be some federal action on the issue, with Democrats, including President Joe Biden, pushing Congress to enact tighter gun restrictions in an effort to prevent more shootings.

An 'actual and articulable' need to carry handguns

The new case, New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Corlett, concerns a New York law governing licenses to carry concealed handguns in public. It requires a resident to show he has what New York calls an "actual and articulable" need to do so.

"The Supreme Court's decision in the case could have an impact on the millions of people living in jurisdictions with restrictive public carry licensing regimes and will tell us how broadly the current set of justices are reading the Second Amendment," said Jacob D. Charles, the executive director of the Center for Firearms law at Duke University School of Law.

According to the Giffords Law Center, although most states continue to require a permit in order to carry a concealed weapon, many states now place few or no restrictions on open carry.

New York Attorney General Letitia James said in court papers that since the landmark Supreme Court cases Heller and the later McDonald v. City of Chicago, courts have held that the right to carry firearms in public is not unlimited and can be subject to regulatory measures consistent "with longstanding limitations on that right."

James told the court that the law requires applicants to carry the handgun in public without restriction to show an "actual and articulable -- rather than merely speculative or specious -- need for self-defense." Lower courts upheld the restriction.

The petitioners in the case are Robert Nash, Brandon Koch and the New York State Rifle and Pistol Association, a group organized to defend the right of New York residents to keep and bear arms. They are represented by Paul Clement, who served as solicitor general during the Bush administration.

In court papers, Clement urged the justices to step in, arguing that the "single most important unresolved Second Amendment question" is whether an individual has a right to bear arms for self-defense "where confrontations often occur: outside the home."

Clement argued that the law makes it almost impossible for an ordinary individual to obtain a license. "Good, even impeccable, moral character plus a simple desire to exercise a fundamental right is," Clement said, "not sufficient." "Nor is living or being employed in a high crime area," he said.

Nash, for instance, requested to carry a handgun for self-defense after a string of robberies in his neighborhood. But he was denied because he did not demonstrate a special need for self-defense. Koch wanted a similar license, and he was able to cite his experience of participating in safety training courses. He too was denied.

Three states -- California, Florida, and Illinois -- and the District of Columbia generally prohibit people from openly carrying firearms in public. Two states -- New York and South Carolina -- prohibit openly carrying handguns, but not long guns, and another three states -- Massachusetts, Minnesota, and New Jersey -- prohibit openly carrying long guns, but not handguns. In the remaining states, people are generally allowed to openly carry firearms, although some states require a permit or license to do so.

This story has been updated with additional details.

Oregon Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 309841

Reported Deaths: 3569
CountyCasesDeaths
Multnomah50840642
Washington34683272
Marion32181388
Clackamas26315270
Lane23632246
Jackson20753255
Deschutes16401100
Umatilla12552125
Douglas10599185
Linn1030285
Josephine8536163
Yamhill737299
Klamath637891
Polk617770
Malheur475867
Benton454027
Coos406469
Columbia320237
Jefferson310446
Lincoln272829
Union266036
Wasco236739
Crook212137
Clatsop210225
Tillamook179623
Baker171920
Morrow166621
Curry166317
Hood River161635
Harney77115
Grant7538
Lake6608
Wallowa50111
Gilliam1364
Sherman1283
Wheeler651
Unassigned00

California Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 4636268

Reported Deaths: 67966
CountyCasesDeaths
Los Angeles144412725849
Riverside3575584802
San Diego3492274006
San Bernardino3468955501
Orange3135295354
Sacramento1498662070
Santa Clara1403871841
Fresno1356471889
Kern1343971515
Alameda1160681320
Ventura976231120
San Joaquin971621615
Contra Costa95595924
Stanislaus800341229
Tulare72812896
San Mateo52172607
San Francisco51808605
Monterey49445565
Solano44061312
Santa Barbara43065500
Sonoma39376376
Merced39279535
Placer36390364
Imperial34235755
Kings30038285
San Luis Obispo28273313
Madera21672258
Butte21205230
Shasta20647276
Santa Cruz20134211
Yolo19118239
Marin17080242
El Dorado15964127
Sutter13055153
Napa1224695
Yuba923461
Nevada845685
Humboldt826284
Tehama821184
San Benito708567
Mendocino681971
Lassen636827
Tuolumne612593
Lake601087
Amador489759
Glenn396430
Siskiyou388841
Calaveras339366
Del Norte334234
Colusa290718
Inyo166239
Mono14935
Plumas12336
Mariposa96712
Trinity71910
Modoc6278
Sierra1980
Unassigned1180
Alpine1000
Out of CA00
Medford
Clear
78° wxIcon
Hi: 76° Lo: 41°
Feels Like: 78°
Brookings
Clear
85° wxIcon
Hi: 84° Lo: 49°
Feels Like: 82°
Crater Lake
Clear
78° wxIcon
Hi: 56° Lo: 26°
Feels Like: 78°
Grants Pass
Partly Cloudy
78° wxIcon
Hi: 79° Lo: 43°
Feels Like: 78°
Klamath Falls
Clear
71° wxIcon
Hi: 65° Lo: 35°
Feels Like: 71°
Warmer tomorrow, smoke potentially returns on Wednesday
KDRV Radar
KDRV Fire Danger
KDRV Weather Cam

Community Events

Latest Video

Image

Monday, September 20th Afternoon Weather

Image

FLU VACCINE

Image

Monday, September 20 morning weather

Image

Sunday, September 19th Weather

Image

Tropical Storm Peter forms as the 16th Atlantic storm of 2021

Image

2021 Man Cave Makeover winner

Image

Sunday, September 19th Weather

Image

Oregon wraps up non-conference play with a steamrolling of Stony Brook

Image

Vidlak makes Beavers debut in Oregon State's 42-0 win

Image

Raiders struggle in road loss to College of Idaho, 29-3