SEVERE WX : Air Stagnation Advisory View Alerts

Supreme Court ruling will make it easier to sentence juveniles to life sentence without parole

The Supreme Court on Thursday upheld the sentence of life without parole for a juvenile offender in a...

Posted: Apr 22, 2021 12:52 PM

The Supreme Court on Thursday upheld the sentence of life without parole for a juvenile offender in a 6-3 decision, rejecting arguments that such sentences should have additional limits.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh penned the decision for his conservative colleagues, holding that a sentencer will not have to make a separate finding that the juvenile offender was incapable of being rehabilitated.

The ruling will make it easier for those who committed their crime under the age of 18 to be sentenced to prison for life without parole.

It also highlights the impact of the court's new conservative majority. Starting in 2005 when then-swing Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote an opinion barring the death penalty for juvenile offenders, the court had been putting limits on sentences for juvenile offenders. Thursday's decision, with three of former President Donald Trump's nominees in the majority, reverses that trend.

Thursday's case concerned Brett Jones, who was charged with killing his grandfather in 2004 in Mississippi when Jones was 15 years old. The two men were engaged in an argument and Jones stabbed his grandfather eight times. Jones' lawyers had argued that before imposing a sentence, a sentencer must make a separate finding, based on facts, that there is permanent incorrigibility.

But Kavanaugh wrote that the court had "unequivocally" stated that a "separate factual finding of permanent incorrigibility is not required before a sentencing of life-without parole." He said under court precedents a juvenile offender could be sentenced to life without parole -- but only if the sentence was not mandatory.

"In a case involving an individual who was under 18 when he or she committed a homicide, a State's discretionary sentencing system is both constitutionally necessary and constitutionally sufficient," Kavanaugh wrote.

Kavanaugh added that "any homicide" is a "horrific tragedy" and that determining the proper sentence "raises profound questions of morality and social policy."

Justice Sonia Sotomayor, writing for her liberal colleagues Justices Stephen Breyer and Elena Kagan, penned a stinging dissent charging the majority with gutting recently decided cases without directly saying so.

"Time and again, this court has recognized that children are constitutionally different from adults for the purposes of sentencing," Sotomayor wrote.

The court's conclusion, she wrote, would come as a "shock" to the court's recent holding that "a lifetime in prison is a disproportionate sentence" for all but a few.

"A sentencer must actually make the judgment that the juvenile in question is one of those rare children for whom LWOP [Life without parole] is a constitutionally permissible sentence," she said.

If a sentencing discretion "is all that is required, far too many juvenile offenders will be sentenced to die" in prison and that the sentences will "not fall equally," Sotomayor wrote. She pointed specifically to the fact that 70% of all youths that receive such sentences are "children of color."

In 2012 the court held that a mandatory sentence of life without parole for juvenile offenders violated the Constitution's bar on cruel and unusual punishment. In 2010 it held that the Constitution prohibits life without parole for offenders who were under 18 and committed non homicide offenses.

CNN Supreme Court analyst and University of Texas Law School professor Steve Vladeck pointed to the change in the court's makeup since the earlier cases.

"With two members of that majority replaced by two of the justices in today's majority, the court now says that states don't need any special reason to impose life without parole on juveniles; all that matters is that the judge has the option of not doing so," Vladeck said.

Oregon Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 392197

Reported Deaths: 5186
CountyCasesDeaths
Multnomah60432839
Washington42082398
Marion39986507
Clackamas32861382
Lane30179358
Jackson24956361
Deschutes23639185
Umatilla15135182
Linn14704179
Douglas13438292
Josephine10201246
Yamhill9787143
Klamath9072147
Polk8248102
Benton611138
Malheur592790
Coos5693107
Columbia433356
Jefferson420866
Lincoln363852
Union339255
Crook336356
Wasco317046
Clatsop262735
Baker220833
Tillamook217045
Hood River214537
Morrow197825
Curry192439
Harney119933
Grant108515
Lake105616
Wallowa76013
Sherman1913
Gilliam1854
Wheeler1141
Unassigned00

California Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 5087907

Reported Deaths: 74561
CountyCasesDeaths
Los Angeles152858627184
San Diego4074794340
Riverside3880835358
San Bernardino3748555967
Orange3346265736
Sacramento1684922447
Kern1578751804
Fresno1568972259
Santa Clara1522681929
Alameda1252361507
San Joaquin1076041834
Ventura1040841191
Contra Costa1038691046
Stanislaus915481417
Tulare861371099
San Francisco56931672
San Mateo56354629
Monterey52521626
Solano47693358
Santa Barbara47345553
Merced45086668
Sonoma43207412
Placer42204470
Imperial38516773
Kings35221362
San Luis Obispo31511360
Madera26233311
Shasta26113458
Butte25476318
Santa Cruz22268224
Yolo21590260
Marin18495249
El Dorado18325166
Sutter14577186
Napa13424105
Yuba1076389
Tehama10282130
Humboldt10183119
Nevada10029105
Mendocino857799
Lassen797656
San Benito782979
Tuolumne774691
Lake7046110
Amador578366
Siskiyou475855
Glenn457436
Calaveras442288
Del Norte376942
Colusa325921
Inyo256746
Plumas19397
Mono18924
Mariposa160718
Trinity99817
Modoc7725
Sierra2180
Alpine1080
Unassigned810
Out of CA00
Medford
Cloudy
42° wxIcon
Hi: 46° Lo: 38°
Feels Like: 42°
Brookings
Partly Cloudy
51° wxIcon
Hi: 57° Lo: 47°
Feels Like: 51°
Crater Lake
Partly Cloudy
42° wxIcon
Hi: 46° Lo: 32°
Feels Like: 42°
Grants Pass
Cloudy
42° wxIcon
Hi: 47° Lo: 41°
Feels Like: 42°
Klamath Falls
Partly Cloudy
35° wxIcon
Hi: 54° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 35°
More developing valley fog tonight
KDRV Radar
KDRV Fire Danger
KDRV Weather Cam

Community Events