Aaron Hernandez's murder conviction reinstated by high court

Aaron Hernandez's murder conviction was reinstated Wednesday by Massachusetts' highest court in a ruling that also ended an antiquated legal rule in which co...

Posted: Mar 13, 2019 12:02 PM
Updated: Mar 13, 2019 2:00 PM

Aaron Hernandez's murder conviction was reinstated Wednesday by Massachusetts' highest court in a ruling that also ended an antiquated legal rule in which convictions were thrown out when a defendant died before an appeal was heard.

The Supreme Judicial Court's decision comes nearly two years after a state judge vacated Hernandez's murder conviction after the former NFL star's suicide.

Hernandez was serving a life sentence for the June 2013 murder of Odin Lloyd. Hernandez hanged himself in his prison cell April 19, 2017, just days after his acquittal on double-murder charges in a separate case.

Massachusetts courts had generally recognized a legal rule called 'abatement ab initio,' or abatement, in which convictions are thrown out if a defendant dies prior his or her appeal being resolved.

But Wednesday's high court ruling called the longstanding legal principle 'outdated and no longer consonant with the circumstances of contemporary life, if, in fact, it ever was.'

Instead, the court said that when a defendant dies during an appeal, the appeal will be dismissed and noted in the court record, and the conviction will stand. The court record will note that the conviction was 'neither affirmed nor reversed because the defendant died.'

'We are pleased justice is served in this case, the antiquated practice of vacating a valid conviction is being eliminated and the victim's family can get the closure they deserve,' Bristol county District Attorney Thomas M. Quinn III said via Twitter.

Attorney John Thompson, who represented Hernandez in the Lloyd case, said he was disappointed with the decision.

'We think the Court departed from its usual standards in coming to this decision and intend to seek reconsideration of that aspect of its decision that applies its newly minted law to Mr. Hernandez's case,' he said in a statement.'The Court has overlooked an essential point of fairness in applying its new rule to this case.'

Attorney Jose Baez, who represented Hernandez in the separate double-murder case in Boston, said the ruling 'will be a hollow and short-lived moment for the Commonwealth, since this decision is not only cruel for Aaron's family, but also disappointing and discouraging to all of those families who seek to clear their loved ones' names, in a flawed system where wrongful convictions are reversed every day.'

At the time of the abatement, prosecutors argued that throwing out Hernandez's conviction would 'reward the defendant's conscious, deliberate and voluntary act' of killing himself and that the abatement rule has no solid historical or legal basis.

'A defendant, who can cut off his own criminal appeal by suicide and stall civil litigation by a stay of proceedings ... has the reins of the entire justice system in his own hands,' prosecutors wrote.

Thompson had argued that the manner of death should not matter -- when a person dies while his conviction is under direct appeal, the conviction should be vacated.

Abatement had generally been recognized in Massachusetts even in high-profile cases of suicide.

John Salvi was convicted of murder in 1996 for opening fire at a Planned Parenthood clinic in Brookline, but his conviction was vacated when he committed suicide in prison before his appeal was heard.

And the death of John J. Geoghan, a priest at the center of the Catholic Church's sexual abuse scandal, also led to the abatement of his conviction.

Oregon Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 174501

Reported Deaths: 2460
CountyCasesDeaths
Multnomah34800568
Washington23412229
Marion20116299
Clackamas15311204
Lane11554144
Jackson9904127
Umatilla796883
Deschutes708272
Linn414263
Yamhill408775
Klamath345259
Polk342952
Malheur342758
Josephine305462
Douglas304365
Benton273218
Jefferson206432
Coos196831
Columbia153826
Union141124
Lincoln129820
Wasco128928
Hood River112429
Morrow107915
Clatsop8918
Crook87819
Baker85614
Curry5939
Tillamook5803
Lake4137
Grant4064
Harney3056
Wallowa1575
Sherman570
Gilliam561
Wheeler251
Unassigned00

California Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 3716579

Reported Deaths: 60994
CountyCasesDeaths
Los Angeles122864123628
Riverside2972154525
San Bernardino2945774550
San Diego2748113674
Orange2688694891
Santa Clara1169712013
Kern1078251322
Sacramento1010581646
Fresno1005001643
Alameda852561477
Ventura802301000
San Joaquin714311334
Contra Costa66927782
Stanislaus603831028
Tulare49383830
Monterey43267357
San Mateo41107560
San Francisco35993517
Santa Barbara33863446
Solano31875239
Merced31196452
Sonoma29679311
Imperial27962719
Kings22766245
Placer21751283
San Luis Obispo20917256
Madera16250239
Santa Cruz15554204
Marin13860226
Yolo13559199
Shasta11677217
Butte11549196
El Dorado9719109
Napa965479
Sutter9268109
Yuba609844
San Benito598263
Lassen566924
Tehama543056
Nevada444775
Tuolumne406664
Mendocino398747
Amador362151
Humboldt358737
Lake340643
Glenn235525
Colusa219816
Calaveras205551
Siskiyou194021
Inyo141738
Del Norte12747
Mono12734
Plumas6906
Modoc4884
Mariposa4247
Trinity3985
Sierra1100
Alpine880
Unassigned330
Medford
Partly Cloudy
75° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 41°
Feels Like: 75°
Brookings
Partly Cloudy
48° wxIcon
Hi: 70° Lo: 47°
Feels Like: 45°
Medford
Clear
75° wxIcon
Hi: 59° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 75°
Medford
Partly Cloudy
75° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 39°
Feels Like: 75°
Klamath Falls
Clear
68° wxIcon
Hi: 69° Lo: 33°
Feels Like: 68°
Very warm Sunday
KDRV Radar
KDRV Fire Danger
KDRV Weather Cam

Community Events