STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

China must beware of summit's unintended consequences

If Donald Trump and Kim Jong Un make peace and agree to denuclearize the Korean Peninsula in their Singapore summit, ...

Posted: Jun 8, 2018 6:18 AM
Updated: Jun 8, 2018 6:18 AM

If Donald Trump and Kim Jong Un make peace and agree to denuclearize the Korean Peninsula in their Singapore summit, the benefits would be felt across the region, not least in China, or so conventional wisdom has it.

Beijing would presumably see the threat of war in a bordering country almost disappear, trade sanctions lifted and a longtime ally in Pyongyang enter a new era of stability.

Not so fast, Asia analysts say. Beware the law of unintended consequences.

"Stability on the (Korean) Peninsula might mean the US is freer to pursue strategic competition with China than it is now," said Corey Wallace, an Asian security analyst at Freie University in Berlin.

That competition has come to the forefront in the run-up to the June 12 summit as US-China tensions have spiked over Chinese military fortifications on man-made islands in the South China Sea.

"Despite China's claims to the contrary, the placement of these weapon systems is tied directly to military use for the purposes of intimidation and coercion," US Defense Secretary James Mattis told the Shangri-La defense forum in Singapore last weekend.

That's a challenge the US is prepared to stand up to both now and into the future, Mattis said.

"Make no mistake: America is in the Indo-Pacific to stay. This is our priority theater," said the defense secretary.

Wallace and other analysts said an easing of tensions in Korea could free up some of the tens of thousands of US forces deployed on the peninsula.

"Those troops are currently committed to Korean contingencies and in most China-related conflicts it would be very difficult for the US to employ forces based on the peninsula," said Timothy Heath, senior defense analyst at the RAND Corp. think tank.

With responsibility for protecting South Korea reduced, those forces could be used to project US power in other parts of the Asia-Pacific such as Japan, Singapore, Australia and the Philippines -- and in doing so, place a renewed focus on countering Chinese influence in the region.

"US forces won't simply pack up and go home," said Wallace.

Beijing must also be wary its longtime ally in Pyongyang doesn't gravitate toward a new friend in Washington.

"Rapprochement could harm China's interests if North Korea starts making decisions that prioritize US over Chinese preferences to maintain good ties," Heath said.

"Like every country in Asia, North Korea has an incentive to seek warmer ties with the US to balance against Chinese power."

For instance, North Korea might be able to negotiate better trade deals with the US and the West than it currently receives from China, its biggest trading partner.

Sam Roggeveen, an analyst at Australia's Lowy Institute, says North Korea's claims to be able to fire nuclear-armed missiles as far as New York or Chicago gives China another advantage, by creating uncertainty between US allies as to whether the US would truly back them up if they were attacked.

Japan and South Korea need to ask themselves, "Would the US risk losing a major city in our defense?" Roggeveen said. "The answer is no."

China can then, in theory, parlay those doubts into whether the US would come to the aid of Japan in relation to the contested Senkaku/Diaoyu island chain in the East China Sea, or even whether the US would defend Taiwan if China moved on it militarily, analysts say.

Remove those doubts, and the US' regional alliance becomes more secure, especially when faced with a common threat.

And whereas North Korea is a threat to North Asian countries, China's influence extends across Asia, potentially drawing more countries into the US' orbit.

But Wallace says there's one summit outcome that could be a nightmare for both China and the US alliance network -- a partial denuclearization where North Korea gives up the long-range missiles that could hit the US mainland but keeps shorter range ones that could still threaten Japan and South Korea.

That could encourage both those US allies to develop their own nuclear arms programs, precipitating an arms race in North Asia.

And there is wide agreement that more nations in the region pursuing nuclear capability would be destabilizing.

"This could have all sorts of cascading effects of which the outcomes are hard to predict," Wallace said.

So what might be the best result for Beijing when the Trump-Kim summit ends?

"A summit which produces nothing tangible, but lowers the temperature" in the region, Roggeveen said.

That's because with the US preoccupied with the North Korea issue, China can continue what it has been doing for the past several years: fortifying its positions in the South China Sea, increasing diplomatic pressure and military exercises around Taiwan, having its ships and aircraft challenge Japan's island claims in the East China Sea, and building and modernizing its armed forces, while forging deeper economic ties around the Asia-Pacific.

At the moment, China sees North Korea's nuclear program to be a "useful tool for its larger purpose," said Roggeveen, "to undermine America's claims to be the strategic power in Asia and take that mantle for itself."

Oregon Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 33291

Reported Deaths: 555
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Multnomah7257140
Marion474395
Washington458160
Umatilla299841
Clackamas244862
Malheur164230
Lane126717
Jackson11715
Deschutes85912
Yamhill76914
Jefferson5458
Polk53515
Linn52513
Morrow5096
Lincoln48113
Union4462
Benton3226
Wasco2963
Klamath2902
Hood River2520
Douglas2394
Clatsop2180
Josephine2032
Columbia1821
Coos1580
Baker952
Crook631
Tillamook530
Lake330
Wallowa321
Curry310
Sherman180
Harney120
Grant100
Gilliam80
Unassigned00
Wheeler00

California Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 815654

Reported Deaths: 15782
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Los Angeles2692846551
Riverside591731216
San Bernardino54849952
Orange535571249
San Diego46985781
Kern32019369
Fresno28517390
Sacramento22438412
Alameda21323408
Santa Clara21294318
San Joaquin20357447
Contra Costa16702206
Stanislaus16496359
Tulare16071263
Ventura12812150
Imperial11877317
San Francisco11238101
Monterey1000872
San Mateo9950150
Santa Barbara9133113
Merced8939143
Kings766180
Sonoma7412122
Marin6727118
Solano641969
Madera455765
San Luis Obispo359729
Placer359645
Butte283744
Yolo282555
Santa Cruz23799
Sutter171711
Napa170513
San Benito134811
Yuba11588
El Dorado11444
Mendocino93918
Shasta88320
Lassen7410
Glenn5933
Tehama5795
Lake55911
Nevada5407
Colusa5326
Humboldt5098
Calaveras31714
Amador29616
Tuolumne2274
Inyo18815
Mono1662
Siskiyou1650
Del Norte1391
Mariposa762
Plumas500
Modoc270
Trinity160
Sierra60
Alpine20
Unassigned00
Medford
Few Clouds
65° wxIcon
Hi: 97° Lo: 56°
Feels Like: 65°
Brookings
Overcast
57° wxIcon
Hi: 66° Lo: 59°
Feels Like: 57°
Crater Lake
Clear
65° wxIcon
Hi: 85° Lo: 48°
Feels Like: 65°
Grants Pass
Clear
68° wxIcon
Hi: 96° Lo: 55°
Feels Like: 68°
Klamath Falls
Clear
65° wxIcon
Hi: 86° Lo: 43°
Feels Like: 65°
Hot and dry week, smoke returns
KDRV Radar
KDRV Fire Danger
KDRV Weather Cam

Community Events

Latest Video

Image

Wednesday, September 30 morning weather

Image

Tuesday, September 29th Evening Weather

Image

MEDFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT RESPONDS AFTER EXPLICIT 'ZOOM BOMBING'

Image

Tuesday, September 29 morning weather

Image

Possible housing solutions after wildfires

Image

Monday, September 28th Evening Weather

Image

Similarities in days had southern Oregonians on edge

Image

Monday, September 28 afternoon weather

Image

Monday, September 28 morning weather

Image

Sunday, September 27 evening weather